Caucus Chaos

I know that it was a couple weeks ago now, but I am finally getting around to blogging about my Democratic caucus day experience. It was interesting and while I had a few bumps as the leader of my precinct, it sounds like I had smooth sailing compared to many folks around the city.

I convinced Joe to be my volunteer because I didn't know if I would be able to count on recruiting anyone on-site. We showed up at the junior high at about 10AM and were told to pick a room. There were several precincts using the school so we made some signs with our precinct number and hung them around the school, but a lot of people who come in didn't know if they were in the right place. Luckily we had a map and they could look to see if their neighborhood fell in the precinct boundaries. Unfortunately, if they weren't in my area I couldn't help them find their room because there wasn't a min directory saying where each precinct would be located. They had to just wander around trying different rooms.

Sign in was a busy process and Joe ended up helping all the people who were pre-registered while I took all the new registrations. You could register as a Dem on the day of the caucus even if you were previously a Republican or independent, and originally I only had 7 voter registration forms in my packet. We went to the post office and grabbed more, which was a good thing because we ended up signing up about 25 new people.

One guy was a volunteer from the Hillary campaign and he brought in another volunteer from a different precinct and asked me to help him. Turns out the precinct chair didn't show up. They didn't have any of their supplies, no forms, nothing. I don't know what they expected me to do. I couldn't leave my precinct, we couldn't combine, and I didn't have any of their info, so I all I could do was give him the Dem's emergency hotline and wish him luck. I did give him some of my voter reg. forms, but it was a small consolation because it wouldn't do them any good for today. In the end I don't know what became of them, but I hope they got some help.

At 11:30 I called the meeting to order and the first item of business was to elect the "permanent chair." I was technically the "temporary chair" and so I nominated myself and explained that I had been trained by the NV Dems to run the caucus so I got a unanimous approval. They told us that we would be easily elected, but I was worried that I would have a contender when one old guy came in early on and made a point of telling me that he had been a precinct captain for several years in the past. Um, good for you?

It was kinda weird because we were in a classroom so all the people sat at the student desks and I was standing at the front of the room like the teacher. We ended up staring at each other and sitting quietly for about 15 minutes because the rules stated you could not do any official counting until noon. It was awkward, but what could I do? I did take some questions and a few people wanted to know when we would be going into the gym. They thought that we would be combining with other precincts at some point. I had to explain that no, we were our own group, totally autonomous from the others and we would be caucusing among ourselves and then electing 4 delegates on our own. It just goes to show how little everyone knew about the caucus process.

Finally noon rolled around and we were able to get things underway. First we had to count up all the people present. I went around and counted but the promptly forgot the final total as soon as I was done. Obviously I would need to start again, but there was one bossy girl who was watching me like a hawk making sure I was doing everything right. How she would know is beyond me, but anyway. So I recounted and marked the number, 49, on the worksheet.

Everyone had already grouped up according to their candidate preference, resulting in a big group for Hillary, a big group for Obama, and 3 people for Edwards. We calculated the viability number, which is the minimum number of supporters a candidate would need in our group to qualify for 1 delegate. The viability was 8. Obviously the Edwards people didn't have enough so I told them they could realign if the wanted to. Two of them got pissed and said they were leaving. They didn't want to do it anymore. Well that threw everything off. To be honest, I wasn't sure what I had to do, but they had taken their ballots with them, so decided to redo the count, which would now be 47 and the subtraction of two people didn't affect anything else. The one remaining Edwards guy decided to go over to the Hillary side and he was cool with the process.

So next we had to count up the supporters in each camp and figure out how many delegates they would get. We only had 4 to award in our precinct. There were 28 for Clinton and 19 for Obama, but based on the math and the rounding, both groups were awarded 2 delegates. Next he groups had to choose 2 people each to become the delegates and go to the county convention which would be held on Feb 23. One lady asked me to do it for the Hillary group (I caucused for her), but I said no, I wasn't interested. In truth, Hillary was my half-hearted second choice and I wasn't really committed enough to pursue any further support. Once Joe Biden dropped out I wasn't even sure if I was going to caucus, but the Dems said I was the only person in my precinct willing to do it so I went through with it.

I think technically everyone was free to go, but I asked them to stay while we reported the results. All 4 delegates came up to the front to fill out the necessary paperwork, sign off on our official documents and then we called into the reporting system. One guy had a phone with a good speakerphone so we could all listen. It was a series of prompts and typing in our official numbers and then we were done.

I nearly forgot to collect our paper ballots, but I got them all. Several people came up to thank me and said I did a good job. I know there were a few bumps and I think I forgot to do some parts, but it went well.

In the aftermath of caucus day any concerns I had a bout my performance were ameliorated when I heard what a debacle the process had been in other places.

There were reports of people (both Hillary and Obama supporters) intimidating an harassing the other side. Some precincts had facilities that were way too small for the turn out, and then there was that abandoned precinct and who knows what happened to them. Aside from the snafus there are several reports of people just being savages with no manners at all. Across the city people who we caucusing on school grounds refused to quit smoking even when asked by the principal to stop. Several schools had no food/drink policies and people ignored them. One school's library was vandalized by people who spilled coffee on books, stuck campaign stickers on tables and left trash everywhere. What is wrong with people?

It was a good experience and it sounds like I did everything OK, but I hope they switch to primaries next time.

Precinct Boss Lady

When I signed up on the Joe Biden For President website back in the summer I was feeling very patriotic and encouraged about our democratic process. I even checked the boxes that said I would be willing to help on election day.

The Biden team contacted me and asked if I would be willing to work as a precinct chair for my local caucus. Sure! Why not? They passed on my info to the NV Democratic Party and then I waited to hear from them.

Time went by and then Iowa had their caucuses. Boy was that depressing. Biden got 1% of the vote and 0 delegates. He promptly removed himself from the race and I was left feeling like I'd lost a limb. Biden was my guy! He (aside from McCain) is the only one with enough experience to properly handle foreign relations. He has been saying all along, we have to pay attention to Pakistan. And then as if to prove him right their government destabilizes and they assassinate the revolutionary voice, Benazir Bhutto. Plus, I really appreciate how much of a straight shooter Biden is, and I don't mind his occasional gaffs because I know that means he is speaking honestly and off the cuff, not in sound bites and carefully calculated phrases.

The NV Dems didn't call for the longest time and after Biden withdrew I was seriously considering not participating in the caucus anyway. Then they finally called and said they still really need my help in my local precinct. I signed up for a 3 hour training on how to run the caucus.

Then Logy had his episode and I didn't go. I felt guilty so I sent an e-mail to the Dems and said if they still wanted me I was willing to do it. I didn't hear from them until yesterday (Saturday) afternoon! Talk about last minute. The caucus is next Saturday. I start my new job tomorrow so I don't have time to take a 3 hour training class, but they said I am the only person willing to do this in my precinct so they really need me. I relented and drove down to HQ to pick up my packet of materials. They told me to read through everything very carefully and then call for training over the phone.

I figured if they can train me over the phone then how difficult can the whole thing be, anyway? Welp, as I read through the booklet, I felt the full gravitas.

I thought that I would just be some helper volunteer. Nope, I am running the show. I am the person in charge of the whole caucus process in my precinct. Basically, the caucus is a simple meeting of all the Dems in this area. We will meet and break into groups according to which candidate we support. Then based on the number of people in support of each candidate, their viability is determined and there may be realignment. Finally we assign delegates to the candidates based on the number of caucus participants supporting them, and then we are done. But there is a whoooole bunch of rules, regulations, math, and formal procedures to make sure it is conducted fairly and with accuracy.

Let's just hope that no one minds that I run the thing by burying my nose in the instruction book and going step by step.

So stay tuned for a recap after next Saturday's shindig. I think I will have Joe come with me (he is an independant and can't participate unless he reregisters as a Dem) and take photos and document the thing so I can put the details up on my blog. I did check the rule book, and technically the caucus is a public event and observers are allowed; they just can't participate or try to influence the proceedings.

Romney: Blatant Panderer and Shredder of the Constitution

On Thursday, Dec. 6, 2007, at the George H. W. Bush Presidential Library, Mitt Romney delivered a speech in which he sought to clarify his religious piety and settle the minds of the religious right who are worried that his little-understood Mormon religion would dominate his decision making.

Instead of affirming the constitutional guarantee of separation of church and state, he just promised a separation of the Mormon church and state. His goal was to calm the worries of the religious right, largely fundamental Christians, by saying that he would not be beholden to the Mormon church, just to Christianity in general.

A full transcript of his speech can be found here. The most astounding part of the speech was the declaration that:

"Freedom requires religion just as religion requires freedom. Freedom opens the windows of the soul so that man can discover his most profound beliefs and commune with God. Freedom and religion endure together, or perish alone."

This is not only a slap in the face to all nonbelievers, but this is also fallacious. Freedom does not require religion, in fact it is incongruous. Freedom, by nature, cannot exist with constraints and rules about belief, actions, and participation. As we all know, where religion is required, freedom is extinguished. By claiming that freedom requires religion, Romney is leaning perilously close to endorsing religious participation as a prerequisite for qualifying for our freedom.

Romney goes further to elaborate on his misunderstanding of the separation of church and state.

"We separate church and state affairs in this country, and for good reason. No religion should dictate to the state nor should the state interfere with the free practice of religion. But in recent years, the notion of the separation of church and state has been taken by some well beyond its original meaning. They seek to remove from the public domain any acknowledgment of God. Religion is seen as merely a private affair with no place in public life. It is as if they are intent on establishing a new religion in America - the religion of secularism. They are wrong.

Yes, he's on the right track; religions are prohibited from meddling in government, and vice versa. (Really, that is all we want!) But again he creates a paradox. By nature, secularism cannot be a religion. Secularism is devoid of religious influence. What he really meant to say was that those of us who are trying to ensure the constitutional guarantee of the separation of church and state by are attempting to redefine The United States as a secular nation. What Romney fails to understand is that this would not be a redefinition of our country, but is rather one of our most defining aspects.

"The founders proscribed the establishment of a state religion, but they did not countenance the elimination of religion from the public square. We are a nation 'Under God' and in God, we do indeed trust.

"We should acknowledge the Creator as did the Founders - in ceremony and word. He should remain on our currency, in our pledge, in the teaching of our history, and during the holiday season, nativity scenes and menorahs should be welcome in our public places. Our greatness would not long endure without judges who respect the foundation of faith upon which our constitution rests. I will take care to separate the affairs of government from any religion, but I will not separate us from 'the God who gave us liberty.'

By giving exalted placement and reverential treatment throughout our government to god it undermines the guarantee of separation in the most basic and blatant form. Just because a specific brand of religion is not declared does not make it benign. Even by mentioning god n general it still excludes those who do not believe in god and those who do not have a god-based religion are still excluded. But, seems like Romney has some company on this. His host, George H. W. Bush has a history of atheist discrimination.

When George Bush was campaigning for the presidency, as incumbent vice-president, he stopped in Chicago on August 27, 1987. At O'Hare Airport he held a formal outdoor news conference. Robert I. Sherman, a reporter for the American Atheist news journal, fully accredited by the state of Illinois and by invitation a participating member of the press corps covering the national candidates, had the following exchange with then-Vice-President Bush.

Sherman: What will you do to win the votes of the Americans who are atheists?

Bush: I guess I'm pretty weak in the atheist community. Faith in God is important to me.

Sherman: Surely you recognize the equal citizenship and patriotism of Americans who are atheists?

Bush: No, I don't know that atheists should be considered as citizens, nor should they be considered patriots. This is one nation under God.

Sherman (somewhat taken aback): Do you support as a sound constitutional principle the separation of state and church?

Bush: Yes, I support the separation of church and state. I'm just not very high on atheists.

I am not alone in my analysis. Here are a couple responses from other organizations.